What Is Farm Animal Welfare and Why Is It Important? (2022)

Animals have been impacted by human food systems in the Americas since the earliest days of human settlement, roughly 30,000 years ago. Hunting by humans in the Americas likely contributed to the extinction of many large land animals like the woolly mammoth and the mastodon during the end of the Pleistocene era. European colonizers later imported extractive agriculture, including the intensive farming of domesticated animals.

In the US, animal farming has increased sharply since the beginning of the twentieth century. The advent of modern industrial technologies and the subsequent rise of profit-driven multinational food and agriculture corporations have drastically changed the character of human-animal relationships. The development of industrial animal farming in the latter half of the twentieth century brought an unprecedented erosion of farmed animal welfare caused by increasing production volume at the expense of animal and environmental wellbeing.

As humanity continues to learn more about animals’ capacity to suffer in confinement, the need for improved farming practices becomes increasingly apparent. It is time for a paradigm shift within the US food system, bringing a new era of plant-based farming and an end to farming practices that disregard animal welfare.

WHAT IS FARMED ANIMAL WELFARE?

The concept of welfare refers to an animal’s health and psychological condition while under the control of human beings. Welfare protocols, policies, and laws condone the use of animals for food but aim to prevent unnecessary harm during raising and slaughtering. In the US food system, most farmed animals enjoy few basic welfare protections, and existing rules overwhelmingly prioritize the financial interests of corporate food producers. For example, animals raised for food are excluded entirely from the federal Animal Welfare Act, and the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act that governs farmed animals lacks an enforcement provision.

Farmed animals play a significant role in US society, although most US residents rarely, if ever, interact with farmed animals directly. Instead, most farmed animals are confined inside industrial production facilities known as concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs). Animals in CAFOs are raised by the tens of thousands under exploitative conditions and slaughtered years ahead of their natural life expectancy. US legislation has a long way to go to resolve the systemic welfare concerns of industrial animal farming.

WHY IS FARMED ANIMAL WELFARE IMPORTANT?

Scientific research has established in a variety of ways that the species most commonly found in the CAFOs of the US food system can experience pain and fear and enjoy comfort—insights that present an ethical argument for eliminating their suffering at human hands. Nevertheless, animal agriculture corporations regard farmed animals solely as products and a means to earn profit. In reality, the animals used in the US supply chains of food, fiber, and experimentation are sentient, sensitive, and emotionally complex.

(Video) Farm animal welfare: its concept, assessment and relation to animal production and human health

  • Cattle: Cattle are emotional beings who can develop close bonds with their offspring and their fellow animals[1] and become excited when learning something new.[2]
  • Pigs: While ranking species’ intelligence is fraught given the challenges and biases within human conceptions of intelligence, pigs are considered to be among the most intelligent of farmed animals. Pigs can use tools,[3] think abstractly and anticipate future events,[4] and are capable of empathy with their fellow pigs.[5]
  • Chickens: In contrast to their unintelligent portrayal in popular culture, chickens can experience psychological distress, boredom, and frustration and are doting parents when allowed to spend time with their young.[6]

FARMED ANIMAL WELFARE ISSUES

As long as farmed animals continue to be considered food commodities within an industrial food system, there will continue to be incentives to violate animal welfare in the pursuit of profit. Standard business practices on CAFOs perpetuate welfare violations on a massive scale through confinement, slaughter, mutilation, and a range of exploitative practices.

SLAUGHTER

Animal slaughter is integral to the farming of animal products, even in supply chains for products like eggs and milk. The 1978 Humane Methods of Slaughter Act is designed to ensure that animal deaths in food production are swift and as painless as possible. In practice, this often means that animals are stunned or rendered unconscious before subsequent processing stages that would be exceedingly painful for conscious animals.

However, there are many ways in which this Act does not adequately safeguard the welfare of animals. Farmed birds, including chickens, turkeys, and geese, are excluded from the Act altogether. One of the most common methods of farmed bird slaughter in the US is known as live-shackle slaughter, a method widely considered inhumane.

Additionally, the Act does not regulate line speeds at slaughterhouses. Lines move quickly, pressuring workers to slaughter and process as many animals per minute as is physically possible. Fast line speeds make it nearly impossible to ensure that animals are successfully stunned before slaughter and increase the risk of severe injury and disease transmission among slaughterhouse workers.

OVERCROWDING AND CONFINEMENT

It is estimated that 1.6 billion animals are living on the roughly 25,000 CAFOs found within the US at any given time. Far from being considered a problem, crowding in these facilities is a feature embedded by design. Confining animals in a facility with a minimal footprint allows animal farms to produce the largest yields while expending the fewest resources. Restricting animals’ movement also makes them easier to control. Battery cages, where many egg-laying hens are still routinely kept, are an example of extreme confinement—providing the birds with living space that is barely larger than the size of their bodies.

PHYSICAL MUTILATIONS

Farmed animals are subjected to routine mutilations that make it possible for the meat industry to confine them in close quarters, such as castration and removal of horns and beaks. Animals are generally not provided any anesthesia for these procedures. Reducing animals’ pain during and after these operations is typically outweighed by concerns over minimizing costs and maximizing profit margins. This calculation results in acute and often chronic welfare degradation for farmed animals.[7]

(Video) The Importance of Animal Welfare

FORCED MOLTING

Forced molting is a practice designed to artificially boost egg production. Withholding food for days or weeks stops egg production but causes hens to lay larger—more profitable—eggs when access to food is restored, and laying recommences. This practice causes birds significant stress, causing aggression, pacing, feather loss, weight loss, and even death.[8] While manifestly cruel and banned in many countries, including India, the EU, and the UK, forced molting continues to be common in the US.

GESTATION CRATES

Gestation crates are another example of extreme confinement, used to house pregnant sows for several months at a time. Typically not much larger than the pigs’ bodies, these crates prevent sows from walking, visiting other pigs, or even turning around. In addition to stress, boredom, and frustration from the almost complete inability to engage in natural behaviors, these crates can also cause injuries and physical ailments. Regions of the UK and EU have banned gestation crates, but they remain common on US hog farms.

CULLING

Culling refers to the killing of animals outside of standard patterns of slaughter. Producers may cull animals that are injured or sick during confinement in a CAFO or at any time when disposal is more cost-effective than keeping animals alive. In the early days of the coronavirus pandemic, meat companies and their producers culled millions of animals when slaughterhouse closures left CAFOs with excess animals to house and feed. An estimated 600,000 pigs and 10 million chickens were culled during these supply chain disruptions.[9] Without established practices for killing animals, some CAFO farmers turned to so-called “ventilator shutdown (VSD),” sealing air inlets and halting ventilators to suffocate animals in their living areas. VSD causes prolonged, panic-filled deaths that are not considered humane.

IS IT NECESSARY TO FARM ANIMALS?

Although human beings can thrive on a diet consisting entirely of plant foods, animal production in the food system is often portrayed as indispensable. Defining the proper role of meat and animal products in US diets is a complicated topic shaped by personal values, differential levels of knowledge and education, the presence of hunger and poverty, unequal access to alternatives, and natural variation in food preferences.

In some global contexts, animal products play a central role in diets due to how food systems are currently structured, but a different food system may be possible. In lower-income countries and regions characterized by smaller-scale and subsistence-based food systems with limited production capacity, animals sometimes supply necessary nutrients for which there are few or no locally appropriate substitutes yet available. In more industrialized food systems, animal agriculture remains dominant despite a growing array of plant-based alternatives. Lopsided capital flows to the animal industry have made meat and animal products exceedingly cheap and ubiquitous across the higher-income nations.

In the US, income inequality and racially-motivated patterns of social disinvestment have also contributed to differential food access between communities, leaving some consumers with few alternatives to industrial animal products. US farming already delivers abundant innovative plant-based foods and meat alternatives, making it increasingly unnecessary to farm animals for human sustenance. With appropriate systemic solutions for unequal food access and sufficient political and social commitment to transition the agricultural sector toward plant-based alternatives, US farming could support a national food system that drastically reduces—or even eliminates—the farming of animals.

(Video) Understanding Farm Animal Welfare Certification

HOW CAN WE HELP FARMED ANIMALS?

US residents consume large quantities of animal products, the vast majority of which come from animals living in CAFOs who experience sub-optimal welfare. One of the most effective ways to help farmed animals is to reduce or entirely withdraw support for the industrial animal agriculture industry. For individuals who have access to alternative ways of eating, this can mean choosing to consume plant-based foods and alternatives to meat. NGOs active in farmed animal welfare and related issue areas can contribute by promoting plant-based lifestyles, shifting the food system away from the exploitation of farmed animals, and advocating for rights-based approaches to animal welfare.

CONCLUSION

The industrial animal agriculture sector causes immense harm to the billions of animals born and raised in the nation’s CAFOs. CAFOs and the model of industrial animal agriculture are fundamentally incompatible with animal welfare. Improving the lives of farmed animals is a transformational project that can ultimately deliver intersectional benefits for the good of people, animals, and the environment. Achieving a dignified, just, and sustainable food system will require eliminating industrial animal agriculture and supporting viable dietary and economic alternatives that do not require the exploitation of farmed animals.

[1] Val-Laillet, David, Vanessa Guesdon, Marina AG von Keyserlingk, Anne Marie de Passillé, and Jeffrey Rushen. “Allogrooming in cattle: relationships between social preferences, feeding displacements and social dominance.” Applied Animal Behaviour Science 116, no. 2-4 (2009): 141-149, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2008.08.005.

[2] Kristin Hagen and Donald M. Broom, “Emotional Reactions to Learning in Cattle,” Applied Animal Behaviour Science 85, no. 3–4 (March 2004): 203–213, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2003.11.007.

[3] Meredith Root-Bernstein et al., “Context-Specific Tool Use by Sus cebifrons,” Mammalian Biology 98 (September 2019): 102–110, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mambio.2019.08.003.

[4] Inonge Reimert et al., “Indicators of Positive and Negative Emotions and Emotional Contagion in Pigs,” Physiology and Behavior 109 (January 2013): 42–50, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physbeh.2012.11.002.

(Video) Animal welfare: consultation opens on Farm to Fork guidance

[5] Lori Marino and Christina M. Colvin, “Thinking Pigs: A Comparative Review of Cognition, Emotion, and Personality in Sus domesticus,” International Journal of Comparative Psychology 28 (2015), https://escholarship.org/uc/item/8sx4s79c.

[6] Lori Marino, “Thinking Chickens: A Review of Cognition, Emotion, and Behavior in the Domestic Chicken,” Animal Cognition 20 (March 2017): 127–147, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-016-1064-4.

[7] H. Cheng, “Morphopathological Changes and Pain in Beak Trimmed Laying Hens,” World’s Poultry Science Journal 62, no. 1 (March 2006): 41–52, https://doi.org/10.1079/WPS200583.

[8] I. J. H. Duncan and D. G. M. Wood-Gush, “Frustration and Aggression in the Domestic Fowl,” Animal Behaviour 19, no. 3 (August 1971): 500:504, https://doi.org/10.1016/S0003-3472(71)80104-5; H. Y. El-Hammady et al., “Performance of Force Molted Chicken Hens Affected by High Temperature. 1. Effect on Egg Production, Feed Consumption, Feed Conversion Ratio and Mortality Rate” (2005), http://www.aun.edu.eg/uploaded_full_txt/3883_full_txt.pdf. .

[9] Jeremy N. Marchant-Forde and Laura A. Boyle, “COVID-19 Effects on Livestock Production: A One Welfare Issue,” Frontiers in Veterinary Science 7, (September 2020), https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2020.585787.

FAQs

What Is Farm Animal Welfare and Why Is It Important? ›

Humane farms are better for animals, people and the environment: Raising animals humanely can use less feed, fuel and water than intensive farming, reducing costs and pollution. Humane farms can create jobs, boost profits and keep local food supplies healthy.

What is animal welfare and why is it important? ›

Animal welfare refers to the state of the animal; the treatment that an animal receives is covered by other terms such as animal care, animal husbandry, and humane treatment. Protecting an animal's welfare means providing for its physical and mental needs.

What is the importance of raising the farm animals? ›

Livestock as a source of income

Animal products not only represent a source of high-quality food, but, equally important, they are a source of income for many small farmers in developing countries, for purchasing food as well as agricultural inputs, such as seed, fertilizers and pesticides.

What are the 3 main concepts of animal welfare? ›

The concept of animal welfare includes three elements: the animal's normal biological functioning (which, among other things, means ensuring that the animal is healthy and well-nourished), its emotional state (including the absence of negative emotions, such as pain and chronic fear), and its ability to express certain ...

What are the 5 animal welfare needs? ›

What are the five welfare needs?
  • live in a suitable environment.
  • eat a suitable diet.
  • exhibit normal behaviour patterns.
  • be housed with, or apart from, other animals.
  • be protected from pain, suffering, injury and disease.
Apr 5, 2022

Why are the 5 animal welfare needs important? ›

The 5 Welfare Needs

Health – Protection from pain, injury, suffering and disease and treated if they become ill or injured. Behaviour – the ability to behave naturally for their species eg. Play, run, dig, jump, fly etc. Companionship – to be housed with, or apart from, other animals as appropriate for the species.

How does animal welfare help animals? ›

An animal welfare organization is dedicated to ensuring that animals are treated as humanely as possible while under human control. These organizations can combine rights advocacy and principles with welfare strategies, the result of which is sometimes referred to as animal protection.

How can we promote animal welfare? ›

5 Great Ways to Promote Animal Welfare
  1. Donate. Animal charity and rescue organizations can always use donations. ...
  2. Foster. If you have the room, the funds, and the time, consider fostering an animal in need. ...
  3. Educate. ...
  4. Spay/Neuter. ...
  5. Volunteer.
Dec 15, 2015

Why is animal welfare science important? ›

Advances in animal welfare science have confirmed the importance of considering animals' psychological states when assessing welfare over time. Although all animals require the basic needs, such as food, water, freedom from fear, good health, express their natural behaviors etc.

Why is animal safety important? ›

While animal cruelty is defined as the act of crime involving the infliction of pain, suffering, or death of an animal, there is the additional dimension of animal neglect which includes withholding basic survival supplies, including food, water, and shelter, which eventually leads to their suffering or death or ...

What are basic animal rights? ›

Animal rights are moral principles grounded in the belief that non-human animals deserve the ability to live as they wish, without being subjected to the desires of human beings. At the core of animal rights is autonomy, which is another way of saying choice.

Why is it important for animals to have freedom? ›

Some measure of freedom is fundamental to satisfying these higher-order needs, and provides a necessary substrate for individuals to thrive and to look forward to a new day. Freedom is the key to many aspects of animal well-being.

Why should we protect animal welfare? ›

Why is animal welfare important? Animal welfare is important because there are so many animals around the world suffering from being used for entertainment, food, medicine, fashion, scientific advancement, and as exotic pets. Every animal deserves to have a good life where they enjoy the benefits of the Five Domains.

How does animal welfare affect production? ›

Animal Welfare in Food Production

Ammonia and other gases from manure can be a respiratory health risk for animals (and workers), especially in poultry houses. Antibiotics and other drugs are used, in part, to control diseases in overcrowded, unhealthy conditions.

Why is animal welfare better than animal rights? ›

Animal welfare supports the use of animals by humans, and seeks to improve their treatment and well-being. Animal Rights is based on the view that animals have similar, or the same rights as humans. Animal rights advocates do not distinguish between humans and animals.

What are the basic needs of animals? ›

All animals have three basic needs: food, water and shelter. These basic needs must be met during the time of the year when the animal is present. It is important that the food, water and shelter be arranged in such a way that they are available to the animal.

What are basic animal rights? ›

Animal rights are moral principles grounded in the belief that non-human animals deserve the ability to live as they wish, without being subjected to the desires of human beings. At the core of animal rights is autonomy, which is another way of saying choice.

How can we take care of animals? ›

How to take care of pets at home?
  1. Feed your pet a good and high-quality foods.
  2. Take them for a walk every day for at least half an hour.
  3. Provide them with the needed vaccination on time.
  4. Keep a clean and hygienic environment for them.
  5. Visit Vet on a weekly/monthly basis.
  6. Engage and do not leave them alone for a long time.
Jul 30, 2019

How can you show care and concern to animals? ›

Ten things you can do to show your pets you love them
  1. Feed your pets healthy food. ...
  2. Exercise your pet. ...
  3. Learn a new language. ...
  4. Pay attention to what he wants to do. ...
  5. Invest in a relationship-based training class. ...
  6. Visit the vet for a checkup. ...
  7. Play more games. ...
  8. Help him conquer his fears.
Feb 13, 2017

Why do we need animals to survive? ›

Animals both large and small are a critical component to our environment. Domesticated animals, such as livestock, provide us food, fiber and leather. Wild animals, including birds, fish, insects and pollinators, are important to support the web of activity in a functioning ecosystem.

What is the difference between animal rights and animal welfare? ›

Animal rights means that animals are not ours to use for food, clothing, entertainment, or experimentation. Animal welfare allows these uses as long as “humane” guidelines are followed.

Why are animal rights not important? ›

Animals lack the capacity for free moral judgements

If an individual lacks the capacity for free moral judgment, then they do not have moral rights. All non-human animals lack the capacity for free moral judgment. Therefore, non-human animals do not have moral rights.

Videos

1. Farmers Take Pride in Farm Animal Welfare Standards - CommonGround
(findourcommonground)
2. Panel: Improving Farm Animal Welfare
(Niman Ranch)
3. Lessons learned in farm animal welfare | Lewis Bollard | EA Global: San Francisco 2019
(Centre for Effective Altruism)
4. Farm animal welfare – with Vet Theeb
(eatfarmnow)
5. Thoughts on Animal Welfare
(MidAtlantic Women in Agriculture)
6. Close-up on Farm Animal Welfare Part 1
(Michigan Farm Bureau)

You might also like

Latest Posts

Article information

Author: Dong Thiel

Last Updated: 11/17/2022

Views: 5939

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dong Thiel

Birthday: 2001-07-14

Address: 2865 Kasha Unions, West Corrinne, AK 05708-1071

Phone: +3512198379449

Job: Design Planner

Hobby: Graffiti, Foreign language learning, Gambling, Metalworking, Rowing, Sculling, Sewing

Introduction: My name is Dong Thiel, I am a brainy, happy, tasty, lively, splendid, talented, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.